Friday, March 31, 2006
Oh Snap! Edwards vs. Meyerhoff (vs. Wilber)
This is only for the hardcore AQAL geeks: #1 Wilber critic Mark Edwards has just posted a short, readable rebuttable to Meyerhoff's Bald Ambition, a book-length critique that's been making the rounds over the last year or two. A quote for total geeks:
With reference to the issue of postformal reasoning, nonexclusion means accepting the truth claims of those who are intimately involved in postformal research. It does not mean accepting the truth claims about postformal issues of those who belong to other research communities in developmental psychology or associated disciplines. We often see debate and disagreement in scientific communities and those debates often occur between communities which operate out of very different methodological and ontological paradigms. Developing orienting generalisations among such groups is probably not possible, definitely not desirable, not is it the goal of an integral methodology to try to do so. Again, Meyerhoff misunderstands this fundamental point and that he does so is evidenced in his treatment of the postformal reasoning topic.
Comments:
<< Home
i don't care! Ken Wilber beats Meyerhoff's ass even while his brain waves are down to ZERO :)
~C (for Cry babies)
Post a Comment
~C (for Cry babies)
<< Home

